Affichage des articles dont le libellé est how to help this player?. Afficher tous les articles
Affichage des articles dont le libellé est how to help this player?. Afficher tous les articles

Okay, how to help this player?

mardi 3 mars 2015

I'll post a conversation from IRC, and highlight the issue.




Quote:








[11:09] <AcatalepsyBeta> What's the best actual book for 'easy' character creation in GURPS?

[11:09] <@Cai> Dungeon Fantasy. Maybe Monster Hunters.

[11:09] <AcatalepsyBeta> I will, uh.

[11:09] <@Cai> Both are specialized genre-based subsystems and have lots of easy fill-in-the-lines templates

[11:09] <AcatalepsyBeta> Acquire those, I think.

[11:09] <@Cai> I don't know of any huge collections of templates for other systems.

[11:10] <Phantasm> DF1, Action!1, and MH1 are probably the top three

[11:10] <@Cai> Oh, Action.

[11:10] <@Cai> Yes, action is very good.

[11:10] <AcatalepsyBeta> DF1?

[11:10] <Phantasm> Dungeon Fantasy 1: Adventurers

[11:11] <AcatalepsyBeta> Those 3rd or 4th GURPS?

[11:11] <Phantasm> Fantasy, Martial Arts, Space, and Traveller: Interstellar Wars have some good templates, too

[11:11] <Phantasm> all those I mentioned are 4e

[11:13] <AcatalepsyBeta> Ah, I see - "occupational templates".

[11:14] <AcatalepsyBeta> Geez those look dense and hard to use.

[11:14] <Phantasm> think of them as "classes"

[11:15] <Phantasm> start with A, B, and C; select from D through H for advantages, select from J through L for disads, and P through X for skills.

[11:16] <AcatalepsyBeta> I can see what they are, Phant.

[11:16] <AcatalepsyBeta> They just look painful to actually read or do anything with.

[11:17] <Phantasm> might just be formatting, then

[11:18] <AcatalepsyBeta> Partially, but I think part of the "Uuugh" of looking at is that it's not always immediately clear what each thing does.

[11:18] <AcatalepsyBeta> Does if I want to sure I understand everything an Archer template is, I need to go look up things from other books just to be sure I'm using my character's abilities.

[11:23] <AcatalepsyBeta> Did no one at SJG look at these character templates and go "wow, these are almost completely unusable for a new player" ?

[11:24] <AcatalepsyBeta> "And maybe this is a problem?"


[11:31] * Cai isn't sure what template AcatalepsyBeta is talking about.

[11:31] <Phantasm> not sure what to say, actually

[11:32] <AcatalepsyBeta> The occupation templates in Space or Fantasy.

[11:33] <Phantasm> those are older books... have you compared them to the templates in DF1?

[11:34] <AcatalepsyBeta> Don't have DF1.

[11:35] <Full_Metalix> They're better, but still a bit lacking.

[11:35] <AcatalepsyBeta> Perhaps a better question: If I was going to run GURPS and expect that no one will read anything until they arrive at the game how do you recommend getting them to make characters quickly?


[11:35] <Fen> >No one will read everything

[11:35] <Fen> Man, those players make me sad

[11:36] <Phantasm> hand them pre-gens

[11:37] <AcatalepsyBeta> Like....I am convinced that some of the players I've played with *could not* make a GURPS character. Not because it's hard, but because it's presented in a way that's practically designed to confuse.

[11:37] <AcatalepsyBeta> Phantasm: There are a lot of people that are allergic to pregens. Also, I don't want to.



So, how can we make character generation even easier for a new player than the templates in DF1 and Action!1?

Okay, how to help this player?

Labels